Murder on the Orient Express

Film and television productions based on the novel by Agatha Christie.

Murder on the Orient Express (1974)

Director Sidney Lumet; writer Paul Dehn; featuring Albert Finney, Richard Widmark, Lauren Bacall, Sean Connery, Vanessa Redgrave, Ingrid Bergman, John Gielgud, Michael York, Jacqueline Bisset, Anthony Perkins, Wendy Hiller

Murder on the Orient Express (2010)

Director Philip Martin; writers Stewart Harcourt; featuring David Suchet, Toby Jones, Eileen Atkins, Jessica Chastain, David Morrissey, Hugh Bonneville, Barbara Hershey

Murder on the Orient Express (2017)

Director Kenneth Branagh; writer Michael Green; featuring Branagh, Willem Dafoe, Judi Dench, Johnny Depp, Penélope Cruz, Derek Jacobi, Michelle Pfeiffer

Murder on the Orient Express


Murder on the Orient Express scene 210

David Suchet is a morally anguished Hercule Poirot in 2010's Murder on the Orient Express.

Poirot's religious mystery play

The most interesting adaptation of Murder on the Orient Express may be the 2010 movie made as part of the Agatha Christie's Poirot series on British television—mainly for the darkness and depth the David Suchet-led presentation brings out the novel.

This production of Murder on the Orient Express may lack the bigger budgets of the cinematic films based on the novel, and the more glamorous casts of the 1974 and 2017 movies. But those elements are not necessary to produce meaningful, moving drama, this adaptation shows.

It helps that it is led by the best Hercule Poirot ever. In the role previously inhabited by such great actors as Peter Ustinov and Albert Finney, and later Kenneth Branagh and John Malkovich, Suchet comes closest—by a long shot—to the detective in the books.

In fact, you could argue he deepens and raises the character beyond Christie's expectations without violating her original vision. The author actually came to find her most famous creation somewhat insufferable, but I have the feeling she would appreciate the man who arises from Suchet's portrayal.

His version of Murder on the Orient Express is framed as a morality play, bringing the moral dilemmas of the novel perhaps to greater prominence than Christie intended but to good effect.

The film begins with Poirot recalling with obvious qualms his most recent case, which concluded with the suicide of the perpetrator he had uncovered. And it ends with his moral anguish over the conclusion of this latest mystery.

Along the way, issues of justice and personal responsibility are repeatedly raised, some based on the text and some invented for the film. An adulterous woman is attacked in the streets of Istanbul as Poirot and other Westerners witness without intervening. An uncomfortable Poirot acquiesces in being given another passenger's first-class berth on the Orient Express. Various other scenes and discussions on weighing the need to follow society's rules versus the dictates of conscience—which, as it turns out, is something every passenger on the train has wrestled with.

Appropriately this Murder on the Orient Express is darkly lit, with shadows shuddering across faces engulfing them entirely as the train rattles into the night and comes to its fateful halt in the snow. Poirot's face bears a continual frown, as his demeanor is also dark in this film, much more so than in Suchet's many previous depictions of the detective.

He is also shown praying and trying to be a good Catholic, the only time I can recall Poirot ever displaying religious feeling. This may sound like a needless addition, but it deepens the character—who is usually portrayed as a bit of a superficial, buffoon. And it fits in well with this adaptation's atmospheric take on the mystery.

Trailer for 2010's dark and moving television movie of Murder on the Orient Express.

Without being the silver-screen stars of other productions of Murder on the Orient Express, the rest of the cast are top-notch, mainly British actors, from Toby Jones as the ill-fated gangster on down. Their jobs are more than to appear for cameos and and pass before Poirot as suspects. They actually have to act. Especially effective is American actress Jessica Chastain as the governess.

Their interaction is shown throughout the film but culminates near the end, as Poirot closes in on the murder's solution. At one point Poirot has angrily excoriated the culprits and they have to decide among themselves what to do, at the same time as Poirot is questioning his own decision.

The tension builds up inexorably to the finale.

Most Agatha Christie works—between covers and on screen—end on light, optimistic notes. The last few scenes in this adaptation make up the most moving such ending ever filmed, a powerful mix of relief and despair, and the continuing mystery of humanity ever knowing what is right or wrong.

— Eric