A Town Like Alice
James Macfadden died in March 1905 when he was forty-seven years old; he was riding in the Driffield Point to Point.
"You don't have to be sorry," she replied. "It was one of those things that seem to happen in a war. It's a long time ago, now—nearly six years. And Captain Sugamo was hung—not for that, but for what he did upon the railway. It's all over and done with now, and nearly forgotten."
I have sat here day after day this winter, sleeping a good deal in my chair, hardly knowing if I was in London or the Gulf country, dreaming of the blazing sunshine, of poddy-dodging and black stockmen, of Cairns and of Green Island. Of a girl that I met forty years too late, and of her life in that small town that I shall never see again, that holds so much of my affection.
A Town Like Alice
Four stories in one
It takes Nevil Shute a long time in this novel to get around to the town of Alice (Alice Springs actually), and even longer to get around to the town like Alice. The building of the new town in Australia is only a minor part of A Town Like Alice, just the climax really of a very long story arc. Most of the novel doesn't even take place in Australia, but rather in England and Malaya.
In fact, this novel is more like a collection of stories, linked by the character of Jean Paget. First there's the story of how a London lawyer for the estate of a Scotsman tracks down his only heir, the aforesaid young Paget, introduces her to her some modest wealth and London culture, and quietly falls in love with her despite the disparity in their ages—without telling her or admitting it to himself.
Then there's the story she tells him of her experiences in the far east during the Second World War, when she was among a number of women taken prisoner by the Japanese and forced to tramp the countryside, with the story being capped by her return to Malaya after the war to help a small village that had taken the women in.
Next is her search for an Australian, Joe Harmon, who had sacrificed himself to save the women.
And finally we get her settlement in Australia and her work to create a livable town "like Alice".
Of these long episodes, the middle one of her experiences in Malaya is by far the most affecting. It's a story of great privation, death, cruelty and partially redeeming humanity, probably the grittiest writing Shute's ever done. Not coincidentally, Shute himself has said this is the only episode ina a novel he has ever based on a real-life incident. And it's entirely engrossing—heart-rendingly engrossing. Its power is what lifts the entire work I believe—why this novel as a whole is one of Shute's most popular and lasting.
However this part also makes the rest of the novel seem rather pallid by comparison. Before and after, Shute seems to be wandering, dabbling in a bit of characterization here and there, indulging in a poignant bit of drama now and then, without any clear purpose.
Now, Shute dabbles very well—his characters can be well drawn and his small dramas can entice for a while—but it's all of minor interest, it all lags a bit, until he brings Paget, with her tragic and inspiring history, back into the spotlight.
Even then, her postwar life doesn't rise to the previous heights or sink to the previous depths. If you get anything from this, it might be how those who went through the horrors of war later had to move on with their lives and find new challenges.
A lot of Shute novels are structured like this: a central kernel of great dramatic, suspenseful, engaging writing surrounded by meandering storylines and ordinary characters who enter and exit without making any enduring impression.
is a novel much like other Shute works, but one of his best.
— Eric McMillan