The Fifth Column and the First Forty-Nine Stories, 1938 edition
First book publication, 1938
The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber
Story, 1936
approx. 12,500 words,
36 pages @350 wds/pg

Listed on:

Greatest Stories

First line: [SHOW] [HIDE]

It was now lunch time and they were all sitting under the double green fly of the dining tent pretending that nothing had happened.

Great lines: [SHOW] [HIDE]

They had a sound basis of union. Margot was too beautiful for Macomber to divorce her and Macomber had too much money for Margot ever to leave him.

Last lines: [SHOW] [HIDE]

"That's better," Wilson said. "Please is much better. Now
I'll stop."

The author: [SHOW] [HIDE]

Ernest Hemingway's works are seldom taught in university, one professor told me, because there is nothing to say about them. I suppose this means Hemingway's.... more

COMMENTARY

Did she or didn't she?

It might be considered Ernest Hemingway's greatest story, if not for the greater popularity of "The Snows of Kilimanjaro", with which it is often paired. Both "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber" and "Kilimanjaro" take place on African safari, and both were likely inspired by a 1932 hunt by Hemingway that also yielded the non-fiction book, Green Hills of Africa. Yet both deal more with human relations than the hunt, and both feature Hemingway's patented cynicism.

But the tone in "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber" is jauntier. It's actually nearly fifty percent longer than "Kilimanjaro" but it's more narrative style makes it seem a quicker read.

The story is about a triangle of a rich American who acts cowardly when facing his first lion, his beautiful wife who mocks him, and the hunter guide she takes up with. Much of the story is told from the perspective of the professional hunter who is perplexed by the behaviour of his wealthy charges.

Their story is deceptively developed. At first it appears Macomber has been the hero of a recent lion kill, but through the sparse banter between the three principals it becomes evident he had in fact embarrassed himself. Only a dozen pages in do we get the full story, as the hunt is recounted in a flashback.

But several twists follow in present time, as Macomber and wife Margot trade barbs, she apparently cuckolds him, and he redeems himself—at least in the eyes of the man she sleeps with—on another hunt. And a final confrontation with a wounded animal ends unexpectedly.   

The "happy" in the story's title is not entirely ironic, as Macomber experiences a new excitement when he becomes—at last—a man of action. The professional hunter, who seems a stand-in for the author, sees this as a delayed passage into manhood.

This may seem to be part of the much-criticized Hemingway machismo, equating killing an animal with proving manliness. But that's not the equation Hemingway is putting forward here. Rather, he's expressing the moment a man stands up for himself against the social structures, represented here by the wife, that keep him weak in the face of adversity. (Yes, as in "The Snows of Kilimanjaro", it's women again who are forced to carry the weight of symbolizing the blame for male weakness.)

But neither is the "short" of the title inaccurate. The individual's happiness does not last. How it is ended—purposely or accidentally—is left inconclusive. There's even some debate over the motivation behind the hunter's response at the end.

But it scarcely matters. As in many a Hemingway tale, the ending is both tragic and fully accepted as the way the world works. Which may be called wisdom or cynicism, depending on whether you share that outlook. 

"The Short Happy Life of Frances Macomber" was adapted into film as The Macomber Affair in 1947 with Gregory Peck as a hunter again (but before his turn in The Snows of Kilimanjaro) and Robert Preston as the ill-fated Macomber. The film is generally considered one of the most faithful cinematic versions of the author's vision—however you value that.

— Eric

missing graphic
The Snows of Kilimanjaro and Other Stories
Get at Amazon: US Can UK

Follow on Twitter:
The Greatest Literature of All Time

Related pages:

Author
Ernest Hemingway

Stories
In Our Time

Novel
The Sun Also Rises

Story
The Killers

Novel
A Farewell to Arms

Story
The Snows of Kilimanjaro

Novel
For Whom the Bell Tolls

Novella
The Old Man and the Sea

missing graphic
The Sun Also Rises
Get at Amazon: US Can UK

missing graphic
A Farewell to Arms
Get at Amazon: US Can UK